Starcast Join the waitlist
The Best 5 Minute Wine Podcast

The Best 5 Minute Wine Podcast

Back Label - The $250 Trick That Fooled Wine Spectator

Jun 18, 2026 · 5m

Coming soon to iPhone. Already have it? “Listen in Starcast” takes you straight there.

On this episode

About this episode

In 2008, researcher Robin Goldstein set out to test how rigorous Wine Spectator really was when handing out its prestigious Award of Excellence. So he built a restaurant that didn't exist — a fictional Italian trattoria in Milan called Osteria L'Intrepido — stocked its wine list almost entirely with bottles Wine Spectator itself had rated poorly, paid the $250 application fee, and waited.